A baby’s birth is always a reason to celebrate, especially when it’s finally time to meet them in person after months of waiting. Even though ultrasounds let us see our babies in the belly, there is nothing better than holding them for the first time.

Babies often surprise us with the unique things about them, like cute dimples or a head full of hair. But the most surprising turn comes when the baby doesn’t look anything like its parents.

This is what happened to one family whose story went popular and made people wonder and speculate online. Read on to find out what happened…

Rachel is a cashier at the Tennessee Celina 52 Truck Stop. On February 17, she gave birth to her son Cash Jamal Buckman. What made people notice, though, was that Rachel and her fiancé, Paul Buckman, are both white, while Cash looks like he is black.

The truck stop posted a picture of the happy family on Facebook and wished Rachel well with her new baby.

“Congratulations to our cashier Rachel and her fiancé Paul Buckman on their baby Cash Jamal Buckman being [born] on Saturday at 6:18pm,” the post read.

But instead of positive responses, the post got comments that called into question Cash’s fatherhood, with some saying that Paul might not be the real father.

Because of the rumors, Celina 52 Truck Stop changed their post and said, “Yes, Paul is the father. Rachel has African American DNA in her which can skip generations and cause a child to be born with darker skin.”

They also said that Cash might have jaundice, which is typical in newborns, and ended the post with the words “Please be kind.”

Even after the truck stop gave an answer, questions and jokes kept going around online.

Someone wrote, “Congratulations!!! I AM sure he looks just like his dad. Where is he?”